top of page

'Being Heumann' review: Siân Heder's biographical drama sits in judgement on the legislators

Writer: S.J.
S.J.
7 minutes ago
3 min read
Ruth Madeley and other actors stopping traffic on the street as a sign of protest.
Apple Original Films

Are we Heumann or are we dancer? Come on in, we'll find out together. Director-writer Siân Heder is back in the limelight as her new biographical drama Being Heumann sets out to take over cinemas and governmental buildings in order to create some necessary change in the United States. Ruth Madeley stars as the titular Judith Heumann who was a bulldozing disability rights activist. The year is 1977, the location is San Francisco. Judith, a disabled wheelchair user herself, and her comrades have been championing a legislation, referred to as section 504, for five years. It would be a costly but important endeavour that would improve the civil rights of disabled folk. As their other attempts have failed to bear fruit, they opt for a sit-in demonstration at the local offices of the department of Health, Education and Welfare (HEW), hoping to finally pressure secretary Joseph A. Califano Jr. (Mark Ruffalo) to approve and sign the legislation.


Judith's posse includes other disabled activists, interpreters, caregivers and helpers. Appearing in some of these parts are Andrew Pilkington (as Hale Zukas), Antwan Tolliver (Brad Lomax), Jon Beavers (Jim Pechin), Madeline Delp (Kitty Cone, Judith's closest companion), Michael Patrick Thornton (Ed Roberts), Ray Fisher (Chuck Jackson) and Roberta Colindrez (Joni Breves). Dylan O'Brien plays Evan White, a news reporter following the group's demonstration.


Seeing how the movie is based on Heumann and Kristen Joiner's memoir 'Being Heumann: An Unrepentant Memoir Of A Disability Rights Activist' and knowing the helmer's recent work, you shouldn't expect many surprises. What you get is a straightforward, sufficiently amusing and very heartwarming story about a group of people who won't give up and are rewarded for their effort. Resilience, the power of activism, dignity, empathy and camaraderie are some of the things it uses as ammo when it decides to aim for your heart. And yes, it sure does hit its target because it's so easy to root for, empathise with and shout alongside these characters. Heder and co-writer Rebekah Taussig's script follows the usual feel-good, crowd-pleasing biopic sheet music, but at least some of the notes have a little bit of emotion since the balance of drama and humour is rather decent and the characters aren't sanded down—they have some spark and grit, fortunately.



Thanks to the period setting and a large ensemble, Heder is also upping her game as a director. Danny Glicker's costume design, John P. Goldsmith's production design, Jamie D. Ramsay's cinematography, and the hair and makeup invite you in immediately and allow you to invest in the storytelling because the milieu feels convincing. But the real MVP of the film is the above-mentioned ensemble and specifically the incredible casting (by casting directors Adam Caldwell and Bernard Telsey). Of course, it is lovely to see authenticity and, as a result, a wide spectrum of bodies and minds that create the human existence, but also a great blend of recognisable faces and fresh talent. That alone would be wonderful, but then the acting itself is also strong across the board. From Madeley and Ruffalo to lesser-known actors, there's terrific comic timing, intensity, pathos and boldness to be found in each of the performances.


Aside from the ever present banality and one uninspired needle drop at the beginning of the film that caused some concern initially, Being Heumann doesn't show signs of disarray. It is really enjoyable from one scene to the next, and it is a story worth highlighting. Sometimes you just want to get cosy and watch a well-told, pleasant movie about an important subject even if it won't change your life. This fits the bill.


Smileys: Casting


Frowneys: None


A few years later, Joseph A. Califano Jr. changed his name to Joseph A. Califayes Jr.


3.5/5



Where to watch:






This article may contain affiliate links, which means that we may earn a commission if you make a purchase through these links. Thank you for the support!

After Misery's logo with the text ''all things film & television'' underneath it.
bottom of page